More people are tuned in to what’s happening in public libraries and public schools than ever before. This is a good thing and it is also long overdue. Many have been shouting about this from the rooftops and from the streets for years.
This tuning in means that the continuing onslaught of awful library bills being proposed across various U.S. states is getting more attention. Again, a great and beyond necessary thing. But with the kind of reception and blasting that librarian criminalization bills are seeing on social media and in the broader media, it’s worth noting that none of these bills are new. Are they connected to what was laid out in Project 2025? Absolutely. However, these bills began long before Project 2025 was spelled out because we, as Americans, have been living the Project 2025 playbook since at least 2021.
What Are Librarian Criminalization Bills?
The common theme of the legislation dubbed “librarian criminalization bills” is that they are all bills which would remove obscenity protections against library workers. Obscenity protections are usually part of state legal codes that ensure those people working in educational institutions like libraries, schools, and museums are able to provide a wide breadth of material to serve their constituents. Those protections intend to curtail frivolous lawsuits against people working in places where materials of all kinds might be present.
Here’s the thing: there is not obscenity in these institutions. Obscenity is defined by the three-part Miller Test:
whether the average person applying contemporary community standards would find the work, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest;whether the work depicts or describes, in a patently offensive way, sexual conduct specifically defined by the applicable state law; andwhether the work, taken as a whole, lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value.Key phrase repeated twice in the Miller Test is “as a whole.”
Copyright
© Book Riot
Did you add any of these to your TBR? Let’s chat in the comments!